Password Protection Page Navigating to Admin Login Page-Why?

Permalink
Hi,

I added a password protection page to the "members" page of our website. Now, when I put in the password, instead of navigating to the "members" page, it takes me to the login page for administrators. It's doing this for church members, too, who are not editors, like me.

Is there a simple setting to change this? I'm not good with coding or anything, so any help would be greatly appreciated!!

Thank you SO much!